For someone who spent most of her teenage years breaking rules meant to keep her safe, much of my adult life has been characterized by self-imposed restrictions. Some of these are for very good reasons: After my colon surgeries in 2006, I went through a battery of tests and received a long list of foods to avoid, as they could cause complications in my stitched-together intestines. Willing to do absolutely anything to avoid another hospitalization, much less surgery, I took “foods to avoid” as “foods I will never again eat.” I wanted to be on the safe side. Extreme, maybe, but understandable—at least to anyone who has experienced colon surgery.
When I got sober in 2008, I decided that since alcohol had blown up my life before nearly ending it, that, too, was something I would never again consume.
Those are the easy ones; the drama of the near-death experiences and the dangerous, painful consequences of getting it wrong make it easier to stay in line than one might think. In the years that followed, I’ve gotten a little more lax about experimenting with certain foods, but largely stick to the original guidelines. And, unfortunately for the Thirsty Katie who still lives deep inside my brain, I remain convinced that I can’t drink alcohol in a moderate or controlled way, so I’m stuck with not drinking it at all.
There’s a lot of security in absolutes. The ones mentioned above have worked well for me, but as someone with very strong opinions and a cornucopia of anxieties, it’s easy for an absolute to quietly become an avoidant crutch.
I first noticed this about myself a few years into sobriety. Friends and coworkers would invite me out to events that were past my self-imposed bedtime and had the possibility of being heavily infused with booze. It made sense that I passed on these invitations, until one day someone invited me to a barbecue and said something like, “You’re invited, but I know it’s not your thing.”
I laughed and nodded before really thinking about what he’d said. Since when was a backyard barbecue not my thing? Sure, there would be people drinking beers, but I had plenty of experience being sober around that. It was at 2 pm on a Sunday. Kids would be there. What, exactly, was so dangerous about this invitation?
The answer, of course, was nothing. I’d gotten so used to saying no that I wasn’t even thinking about the ask. When I did think about the ask, I wasn’t sure why I was still hesitant. I knew I wasn’t going to pick up a beer in front of all the coworkers who knew I was sober. In reality, I was worried it would be awkward or uncomfortable. If it was, I could point to those feelings and say, “Danger! Those feelings might make me want to drink! Therefore, this is unsafe!” But even as I was thinking it through, I knew that was bullshit. Somewhere along the way, I’d started using the pretense of safety to avoid what was actually potential discomfort.
Distinguishing between what is emotionally/psychologically unsafe vs. what’s merely uncomfortable is an ongoing challenge for me. I am a creature of habit. What feels comfortable inherently feels safe, though intellectually I know that’s not always true. There was a time when a bottle of Stoli guaranteed my comfort and nothing about it was safe.
As someone who is high-anxiety and prone to panic attacks, going outside my comfort zone is never easy, but it is vital. It’s vital for personal growth, for compromising with loved ones, and for showing up for the people I care about. But in the right conditions, the panic switch flips, and what started as discomfort suddenly feels exactly like danger.
Bet you didn’t think this was all leading up to a story about feral kittens, but here we are.
Six months ago, four tiny kittens appeared behind a pile of compost at the edge of our property. It wasn’t hard to tell where they came from: a feral grey tabby had been lurking around the property for a year or so, and a fat black cat named Bruce from across the street kept finding his way over for reasons that are now quite obvious.
There were three grey tabbies and one black kitten, all of whom were beautiful and cute enough to make a steadfast dog-person consider a life with cats. But I really, really, really didn’t want cats. We’d had our new puppy for about a year, and that was more than enough energy to deal with. Plus, I’ve always vowed that I would never live in a house with a litter box. They are stinky and gross and I believe in animals pooping outside.
Also, we live in a rural area! People’s cats get eaten by predators all the time! If we had a cat, it would have to be indoor-only, or we’d be leaving it at the mercy of coyotes, eagles, and other things that eat kittens. And how could we have an indoor cat with an overexcited puppy? The idea sent my control-freak, way-too-intense-about-animals anxiety skyrocketing.
At the time, we had no reason to worry about such things (not that it ever stopped me). These kittens, while cute, were feral, and their mom was still hanging around, bringing them dead mice and doing other gross-but-good-cat-mom things. The internet told us the responsible thing would be to trap them, spay and neuter them, and then either return them to the yard as feral cats or try to get them adopted.
We were on board with the idea, just not yet. They were too skittish, and their mom was still actively caring for them. We sat back and watched the cuteness play out. One of the kittens was much smaller than the rest and seemed to have underdeveloped eyes. Not thinking we’d ever have a reason to share her name with anyone, we started calling her Runty.
All was well for a few weeks until all the cats disappeared and left Runty behind. We found her hiding from the rain under the car, mewing the saddest, tiniest, most desperate meow. She looked at us with her weird little mousy eyes, terrified of us but equally distraught by having suddenly lost her family.
I may not be a cat person, but I am also not a sociopath. In what world am I going to leave Runty out in the cold? We have a sunroom attached to our porch, so we left the sliding door open a crack and put some food inside, hoping she’d be warmer and better protected than she was under the car.
This went on for a few agonizing days until one evening I looked out the window, and Runty was curled up on the porch with another cat. Runty’s sister had returned. Naturally, I immediately burst into tears, brought them big dishes of food, and brought a space heater into the sunroom.
Now, Runty and Boomer (short for Boomerang because she came back) AND their scofflaw brother TK (Third Kitten) are all living on the sun porch as (spayed and neutered) indoor-outdoor cats. Doris Day (the dog) still gets overexcited when they’re inside, TK still won’t let us touch him, Runty seems utterly confused and defenseless, and Boomer is so good at sneaking into the house and hiding somewhere that she could be in my office right now, and I’d have no clue. I’m terrified that they’re going to get eaten by something. The sunroom has gone from a lovely little reading room to a deranged cat zoo—complete with an enormous litter box. I don’t know what to do about any of it.
When I pick Boomer up and hold her to my chest, and she starts purring so contentedly, it’s like there’s a little love motor hiding inside her body, soothing the anxiety in us both. Purring, man. What an incredible feeling. I know this all might end in heartbreak and disaster, but have you ever felt a kitten purr like this?
*
If you enjoyed this post, please like, comment, or share it. This helps others find the newsletter!
Want to show your support of AASL without committing to a paid subscription? Leave a one-time tip here.
Send questions and feedback to askasoberlady@gmail.com. By sending a question, you agree to let me reprint it in the newsletter with your name redacted or changed. Emails may be edited for length or clarity.
I’m not a doctor or mental health professional, so my advice shouldn’t be construed as medical or therapeutic. You are free to take or leave it.





Runty is the cutest little thing ever! Also, you're going to love being a cat person.
😭❤️